American University

Men’s Basketball
2013-14, Jesse Reed, So.
2014-15, Jesse Reed, Jr.
2016-17, Charlie Jones, So.

Women’s Basketball
2006-07, Liz Hayes, Jr.
2007-08, Liz Hayes, Sr.
2011-12, Alexis Dobbs, So.
2012-13, Alexis Dobbs, Jr.
2013-14, Alexis Dobbs, Sr.
2014-15, Jen Dumiak, Sr. 
2016-17, Lauren Crisler, Sr.
2017-18, Emily Kinneston, Sr.
2018-19, Cecily Carl, Sr.

Men’s Cross Country
2003, Pat MacAdie, Sr.
2005, Stephan Hallinan, So.
2006, Conor Lanz, Gr.
2010, Colin Eustis, Sr.

Women's Cross Country
2002, Jen Baclawski, Jr.
2003, Keira Carlstrom, So.
2005, Keira Carlstrom, Jr.
2006, Keira Carlstrom, Sr.
2009, Greta Wicklund, Sr.

Field Hockey
2002, Magdalena Aguilar, Sr.
2003, Laura Miller, Jr.
2005, Maureen Daniel, Sr.
2006, Heidi Hershberger, Sr.
2008, Irene Schickhardt, Sr.
2014, Grace Wilson, Sr.
2015, Natalie Konerth, Jr.
2016, Natalie Konerth, Sr.
2017, Maura Jacobs, Jr. 
2018, Maura Jacobs, Sr.
2020-21, Aidan Rossman, Jr.
2021, Aidan Rossman, Jr.
2023, Bryn Underwood, Sr.
2024, Bryn Underwood, Gr.

Women's Lacrosse
2004, Tara Michael, Sr.
2006, Moriah Linnell, Sr. 

Men's Soccer
2001, Adam Rosen, Sr.
2010, Matt Makowski, Jr.
2011, Matt Makowski, Sr.
2012, Colin Seigfreid, Jr. 

Women's Soccer
2007, Krystn Hodge, Sr.
2011, Jenna Stasiewicz, Sr.

Men's Swimming & Dive
2001-02, Ethan Bassett, So.
2005-06, Val Fomenko, Sr. 

Women's Swimming & Dive
2001-02, Jessica Lidstrom, So.
2002-03, Jessica Lidstrom, Jr.
2005-06, Meaghan Thiel, So.
2022-23, Mimi Watts, Jr.
2023-24, Mimi Watts, Sr.

Men's Indoor Track & Field
2001-02, Frank Malpigli, So.
2003-04, Matt Seymour, Sr.
2015-16, Brendan Johnson, Jr. 

Women's Indoor Track & Field
2003-04, Keira Carlstrom, So.

Men's Outdoor Track & Field
2004, Matt Seymour, Sr. 
2014, John Pope, Sr. 
2023, Row Sullivan, Sr.

Women's Outdoor Track & Field
2003, Jen Baclawski, Jr.
2004, Keira Carlstrom, So.
2005, Keira Carlstrom, Jr.
2011, Erin Koch, Sr. 

Volleyball
2001, Karla Kucerkova, So.
2002, Karla Kucerkova, Jr.
2003, Karla Kucerkova, Sr.
2010, Cassandra Ricketts, Sr.
2011, Rebecca Heath, Sr.
2013, Monika Smidova, So.
2014, Monika Smidova, Jr.
2015, Monika Smidova, Sr.
2019, Olivia Wassner, Jr.
2020-21, Helena Elbaek, Sr.